There’s nothing quite like the thrill of unboxing a brand-new pair of shoes. But we’ve all been there—the first time we try them on, our excitement quickly turns into sore feet, blisters, and frustration. New shoes, whether they’re stylish heels, elegant flats, or snug leather boots, often need a little time before they feel like they were made just for us.
We understand how frustrating this can be, so we’ve put together our tried-and-true tips and tricks for breaking in shoes comfortably and safely. Follow these steps, and soon your new shoes will feel as if they were custom-fit for your feet.
Affiliate disclosure: Some of the links in this article are affiliate links. This means that if you choose to purchase a product through one of these links, we may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you. We only recommend products and tools that we personally trust and believe will be helpful for our readers. Full disclosure here.
1. Start Slowly
The most important rule is to take it slow. Many people make the mistake of wearing new shoes all day immediately, which often leads to blisters and discomfort. Instead, we recommend starting with short sessions: wear your new shoes around the house for 15–30 minutes at a time. Walk, stand, and even move around doing light chores.
This allows the shoe material to gradually adjust to your feet and reduces the risk of painful rubbing. Over a few days, your shoes will begin to mold perfectly to your shape.
2. Thick Socks Are Your Friend
One of our favorite tricks, especially for leather shoes or boots, is using thick socks. By slipping on a pair of thicker socks, putting on the shoes, and walking around the house, we can gently stretch the material without overdoing it.
This works wonders for stiff shoes and helps shape them to our feet more naturally. For very tight spots, wearing multiple pairs of socks for a short period can give the material just the right stretch.
3. Apply Gentle Heat
Leather shoes in particular respond very well to a little warmth. We like to use a hairdryer on a low setting—heating the tight areas for a few seconds while flexing the shoes with our hands or feet. The warmth softens the material, making it more pliable and easier to mold to our feet.
Just be careful not to overheat the leather, as too much heat can damage it. A little warmth goes a long way, especially around the toes or sides that feel stiff.
4. Use Shoe Stretchers
For shoes that feel tight in specific areas, shoe stretchers are a game-changer. By inserting a stretcher and leaving it for a few hours or overnight, we can widen or lengthen the problem areas gently. Some stretchers even allow us to target specific spots, like the toe box or heel, giving a custom fit without waiting weeks.
Stretchers are especially useful for high-quality leather shoes or designer heels that are expensive and worth protecting.
Advertisement
5. Protect Our Feet
Even with all the breaking-in tricks, some shoes may still rub in certain areas. That’s where Moleskin, gel pads, or blister stickers come in. These protect our heels, toes, and sides, allowing us to walk comfortably while the shoes adjust.
We especially recommend this for pointed-toe heels, strappy sandals, or stiff flats. Small padding can prevent blisters and save us a lot of pain.
6. Condition Leather Shoes
Leather shoes break in faster and last longer when we take care of the material. Applying a small amount of leather conditioner or cream keeps the material soft and supple.
This doesn’t just make the shoes more comfortable—it prevents cracking, scuffs, and wear, making our investment last longer. Conditioning is a simple step that keeps shoes looking brand-new while speeding up the breaking-in process.
Advertisement
7. Bend and Flex
Before wearing new shoes, we like to bend and flex them gently. Focus on stiff areas, like the soles, toes, and heels. Flexing the shoes by hand helps loosen the material and reduces friction when we first wear them.
For sneakers, a little bending at the sole can make them more comfortable for walking or running. For heels, gently pressing the heel cup or toe box can reduce rubbing.
Bonus Tip: Patience Is Key
Breaking in shoes isn’t something that happens overnight. Even with the best techniques, we need to allow time for the shoes to adapt to our feet. Rushing the process often leads to blisters, soreness, or even damaging the shoes.
By combining short wear sessions, gentle stretching, protective pads, and proper leather care, we can make almost any new pair feel comfortable and supportive.
We’re here to help make your shoe-wearing experience enjoyable from day one. New shoes should make us feel confident, stylish, and ready to take on the day—not sore, frustrated, or cautious.
By following these tips—starting slowly, using thick socks, gentle heat, shoe stretchers, protective padding, conditioning leather, and flexing the shoes—we can turn almost any new pair into a comfortable, well-fitted favorite. With a little care and patience, our shoes can feel like they were made just for us.
Advertisement